The Tale of the Bookish Babysitter vs. The Tale of the Dream Machine

On the spooky 242nd episode of Big Orange Couch: The 90s Nickelodeon Podcast, Andrew, Joey, and Logan debate The Tale of the Bookish Babysitter (Logan) vs. The Tale of the Dream Machine (Andrew), as Joey judges. Categories include: story, the midnight society, plot device, characters, and scariness. Plus, ratings, name the episode, candy corn returns, a close decision, and so much more!